Tallest Tower

90-120m
Ages 5+

Introduction

Make a tower

Who can build the tallest cardboard tower? But not all is fair in this competition, where students experience inequity first-hand and then explore it through the lens of resource inequality.

Subjects
English, HASS, Visual Arts, HPE.

Objectives

Preparation

Resources

Important Considerations for this lesson:

  • Age Appropriateness: Adapt the depth of the discussion and the complexity of the concepts to the students' age level.

  • Connections to Current Events: Connect the activity to real-world examples of resource inequality to make the learning more relevant.

  • Sensitivity: Approach the topic of resource inequality with sensitivity and respect for diverse perspectives.

Lesson Steps

45 minute lesson

  1. Warm-up (5 min)

  2. Discuss Key Concepts (5 min)

  3. Creation (25 min)

  4. Reflection (5 min)

Warm-up

Time allocated: 5-10 minutes

Inequalities

  • Ask students to examine an image and answer the following questions with as much detail as possible.

    • What is going on in this picture?

    • What do you see that makes you say that?

    • Finish this sentence stem: “I wonder…”

Suggested Script: 

“Could you live in a house like this? Why or why not? Not all housing is fair and equal. This is a real house someone lived in during the Great Depression. Many families struggled to survive and built houses out of refuse and trash - these structures are known as shanties. Today, many people experiencing homelessness still live in unfair and unequal conditions similar to this.”

Activity

Time allocated: 25 minute


Part 1 - Tower Building
Introduce Unfair Makedo Tower Activity 

  • Suggested Script:

    “Today we will explore the concept of unfairness by competing to build the tallest tower with Makedo tools and upcycled cardboard. You will have the opportunity to experience inequality first hand.”

  • Divide students into four equal teams. 

  • Distribute Makedo tools and cardboard. 

  • Begin by giving each team an equal number of tools and cardboard, and then explain the following rules, which will provide each team with advantages and disadvantages. (If desired, let students all build equally for five minutes, and then introduce the rules.)

Rules

  • Team 1 has all members of their team, except two people, who must be reallocated to other teams.

  • Team 2 must relocate all their Makedo Scrus to the far end of the room or outside of the room. They can only access their Scrus by sending one person to collect one Scru at a time.

  • Team 3 is only allowed to use one Scrudriver. Redistribute their other Scrudrivers to team 4.

  • Team 4 is given extra cardboard and extra Safe-Saws and Scru-Drivers.

  • (If more teams are needed, adjust rules as necessary.)

  • Part 2 - Group Discussion

  1. Reflect on the activity. How did you feel when the conditions for the teams were changed? 

  2. Watch the following video on equity and equality, then define the term ‘equal’. 

    Suggested Script:

    Equal means everyone gets the same no matter their needs or circumstances.

  3. Discuss how teams were advantaged or disadvantaged by the rules. Did the team that had the most significant advantage win the competition? How did that make people feel?

  4. Can you give any examples of how the inequity of resources in the game is reflected in the real world? Hint: Consider the distribution of resources worldwide, such as food, water and energy.

    Suggested Script:

    Resources are things people need to survive or live comfortably. Natural resources (like sunlight, air, water, land, minerals, plants, and animals) are spread out based on physical factors such as landscape, climate, and height above sea level. Although there are sufficient vital resources, such as food, water, and energy, for everyone, not everyone has equal access to them. You may be fortunate enough to have an abundance of food, while others in developing nations may not. This is referred to as 'resource inequality.'

  5. Who in the world is most disadvantaged and advantaged by resource inequality?

    Suggested Script:

    This depends on the natural resources available in a particular location. For example, areas with easy access to clean water, such as a stream or a city with a water supply system, are less likely to run out of water. However, in a desert where there is no natural water or water pipes, people often need assistance to access water.


Video: Equity and Equality

Reflection

Journal Prompts

  • Where do you see a lack of equality in your everyday life? How does that make you feel?

  • How would your daily life might be impacted if you didn’t have easy access to resources such as water, food and energy?

  • Are there any small actions that you could undertake to help make the world a more equal place? What are they?

Extension

Take It Further

  • Engineer Investigation - Invite students to explore engineering and the Engineering Design Process, then use their findings to make structural improvements to their towers.

  • What She Makes - Women are often responsible for making our clothes in developing countries. Invite students to explore the What She Makes resources to investigate how three brands they wear or know of stack up in creating a fairer fashion industry. Discuss what they learned and any feelings that arose while exploring the brands.

  • Design An Experiment: Students design an experiment to demonstrate inequality between four groups, like the one we did with our towers. One has ideal light, water, and nutrients, and the others have decreasing amounts of these.

  • Graph It: Students measure and graph the heights of their towers in a bar chart. On the X axis, give the group a degree of disadvantage, and then draw a conclusion from your findings based on the data.

Further Resources

Alignment to Standards

These standards are highly relevant to this activity. For a complete list, please refer to the framework websites. This list can be tailored for your class.